A scorecard for women who stopped checking years ago
That familiar advice still has some merit, though only so far. If you enjoy your work, pay becomes less central. Having a manager who backs you, projects that mean something and teammates you can rely on are worth far more than a slight bump in pay, and fixating on every dollar tends to exhaust people over time. Many women who jumped ship for a 15% bump in the Triangle now find themselves less happy and paid no better.
There is a counterpoint worth taking seriously: caring deeply about your job is precisely when you are most likely to be underpaid, since the people setting your compensation can see how committed you are.
1. Loyalty is priced in
Your salary is not a verdict on how much you deserve. Instead, it tracks what your employer would spend to find someone to fill your seat, weighed against the chance that you might leave. McKinsey and LeanIn's 2025 report found that only 54% of companies treat women's advancement as a high priority, and the ones that don't are hardly going to offer a correction unprompted. Three warning signs: you haven't had a single outside conversation in three years, every raise you've received has been the standard percentage, and no one has ever made you a counteroffer because you have never given them a reason to.
2. The work grew and the number didn't
Research cited in the book The No Club found that at one professional-services firm, women logged about 200 more hours a year than men on work that earns no promotion credit, and were asked roughly 50% more often to take it on. When you love the role, agreeing to extra requests comes more easily. Three warning signs: your scope has expanded with no change in title, you're training colleagues you suspect earn more than you do, and the planning, note-taking and offsite logistics keep landing on your desk without anyone ever tallying them.
3. The market moved while you were busy
In a growing number of states, employers must now publish pay ranges, which means anyone in the Triangle can see where the market sits, though you probably haven't looked yet. Three warning signs: a new hire at your level started above you, a recruiter quoted a figure that caught you off guard, and you can't name the salary band for your own role, let alone where you fall within it.
Cases in which the conventional guidance still fits the facts, even in a fast-growing region like Raleigh.
Giving up a role you care about over a gap of 5% is rarely a sound move. The advice only breaks down when it becomes an excuse to stop looking at your numbers. Caring deeply about your work and understanding its market value can coexist without any tension. The women who are paid fairly in roles they care about are usually the ones who kept their pay current while staying put.
A better next step
Tally your answers against the nine signs above. Three or fewer, and you're likely fine; just review once a year. Four to six, and your pay is drifting; spend thirty minutes this week on a market check, pulling three posted ranges for your title in the Raleigh metro and noting the midpoint. Seven or more, and you are effectively subsidizing your employer, and affection for your work isn't a line item on a budget.
Next, raise a single question with your manager during your regular one-on-one, keeping your tone calm and matter-of-fact: "I'd like to understand where I fall in the salary range for my level, and what it would take to reach the midpoint." Asking this is not an ultimatum. You're asking a straightforward question about numbers, and a manager who sidesteps it has answered it.
Out of the nine signs, how many described your own situation?