What a decade of "lean in" got wrong, and what actually moves women up

Negotiating the latest job offer was something fifty-four percent of the women here had done. For men, that share came to forty-four percent. Even so, the women earned less. This comes from Kray, Kennedy and Lee at Berkeley Haas, released in 2023 and covered by Fortune, and it ought to end ten years of guidance in a single sentence.

A popular idea called the "lean in" movement suggested an easy answer to the puzzle. Women earn less and advance more slowly because they don't push for more. Teach them to speak up, run them through confidence workshops and negotiation seminars, and tell them to own their value, and the gap will shrink. Employers found that story comfortable, because every remedy it recommended put the burden back on the individual woman. The Berkeley numbers undercut it. Women are asking more often than men do. They ask, and still end up short.

Origin of the figure

The research was run out of the Haas School of Business at Berkeley, led by Laura Kray with Jessica Kennedy and Margaret Lee, and focused on how people negotiated around recent job offers. What caught researchers off guard was that women actually negotiated at a higher rate than men. What really counts is that, even so, their final pay remained lower. One study proves only so much. It doesn't establish that women negotiate better or worse, and it doesn't pin down every cause of the difference. Even so, it leaves the most straightforward explanation off the table. A gap can't reasonably be pinned on a behavior the women are performing more often.

Work from other researchers lines up with this finding. Studies of the likability penalty keep finding that an identical request sounds assertive coming from a man and pushy coming from a woman. Put these two bodies of evidence side by side and the question changes from "why don't women ask?" to "why does asking get women penalized?"

How this plays out in practice around Raleigh

Imagine you're at the offer stage for a role you want, perhaps at one of the Triangle's large employers. You've looked at three postings with salary ranges, you know roughly where the midpoint falls, and you ask for it, calmly, with reasons. A recruiter in Cary tells a candidate she will "look into it," then comes back with an increase of two thousand dollars, framed as a real stretch for the company. Down the road in Apex, a different candidate applying for that same role asks for the upper end of the range and ends up nearly there, which the hiring team calls "competitive." You negotiated, too. He negotiated. Even so, the outcomes diverge, and no words you chose on that call could have altered the result, since the verdict on what your ask was worth had been settled before you ever opened your mouth.

What it means for you here

Whenever someone in Garner or Wake Forest has told you that you simply need more confidence, it's worth asking what that counsel actually achieved. It placed the problem inside you, where fixing it costs the organization nothing. In a 2021 Harvard Business Review piece, Tulshyan and Burey made a similar argument about imposter syndrome: the label turns a systemic problem into an individual one. Framing the problem as a confidence gap repackages the very same dynamic in softer language. You don't need repairing. The process needs examining.

What to do next

Ask about the pay band instead of your personal worth. Try "What is the posted range for this level, and where does this offer sit within it?" A growing number of states now require posted ranges, so the question has a factual answer. Then ask the one question no one can pin on your personality: "What would it take to reach the midpoint?" You're negotiating with the numbers, and the numbers don't come across as demanding.

When did you last ask, and what did that ask end up costing you?