Glass cliff or breakthrough: four questions that tell you which one you're looking at

The board chair reaches out to you by phone on a Sunday, when most people are off work. Across six quarters the division has operated at a loss, and both of the women who preceded you in the role were removed within a year and a half of taking it. Accepting would bring a bigger title, a raise of $90,000, a seat on the executive committee, and a mandate that, when you parse its wording, comes down to "fix what two people before you could not, using the same funds and the same board." You are 53 years old. For five years you have been readying yourself for a position of this magnitude, so you grasp exactly why it is being offered to you at this moment. The chair wants your decision by Friday.

What you need to determine is not whether you have the ability to do this. What matters is whether this opportunity is a dead end or a turning point, though seen from afar the two appear identical.

Path One Say yes and take the role exactly as offered

The downside is easy to see for anyone in the Triangle who looks closely. Should the division fail to recover, you will end up as the third person on that list, and people tend to remember lists. Organizations seldom ask why three presidents in a row struggled. They ask who the fourth should be, and the fourth typically shows up with a bigger budget and a longer leash. Russell Reynolds found, in a small sample, which you should treat as a hint rather than a verdict, that women CEOs averaged 5.2 years in the role versus 8.1 for men. Brief terms in leadership seats tend to repeat in predictable ways.

Path Two Decline the offer outright

Saying yes also carries a cost that others will be able to see. Positions of this scale don't open every year, and "she passed on it" is a story that gets around. You keep your record spotless, but you may be giving up your one shot to prove you can run something that is losing money. Sometimes a cliff is just a cliff. Occasionally it is the difficult assignment no one else would touch, and whoever steps in earns the recognition for it.

Path Three Agree, but set the conditions yourself

Agree, but attach your conditions and put them in writing before any signature goes on paper. A defined runway, a named board sponsor, a budget line that didn't exist for your predecessors, and an eighteen-month success measure that is more than simply "profitable." The risk is that you may hear no, and a no to reasonable conditions is one of the most useful answers you'll get all year. It signals that they want a familiar face on the office door, not an actual recovery plan.

Counsel from seasoned leaders

Leaders who have taken on cliff jobs and come through them tend to ask four questions first.

First What did the last two leaders say about why they left, speaking for themselves rather than through the chair? Call them. They will tell you.

Second Which factors have shifted in the time since? If the explanation boils down to "it was about you," that is a flattering remark, not a strategy.

Third Which board member is willing to share responsibility with you for how this turns out? If no one is willing to name a specific individual, then no one will defend you once the first disappointing quarter arrives.

Fourth Before you start, write down what a win looks like at eighteen months. Without that on paper, they have no fair basis for evaluating you, yet they will evaluate you regardless.

The result

Everything depends on the first question you face. If the last two leaders were positioned to fail and only the title has changed hands, turn it down, or negotiate until something tangible is on the table. If real substantive changes have been made, accept, provided it is documented and you have a sponsor on the board. A true breakthrough tends to resemble a dead end that comes with funding attached.

Your ballot

What would your next move be? You can accept, decline, or accept on terms you set yourself. Cast your vote below. We'll publish the results next week, along with the first question most of you said you'd ask.