The three things they're judging, and none of them is your wardrobe
Executive presence tends to come as feedback that offers no manual for how to act on it. Somebody suggests you need more of it, nobody can say what that looks like, and soon enough you're rethinking the blazer you wore that morning. Pause there. The people evaluating it are weighing three things: whether they can trust you with a decision, whether your voice registers when you talk, and whether you hold your composure when things go sideways. Your wardrobe doesn't appear anywhere on that list. The fuzziness is not accidental. Research on the likability penalty has repeatedly found that the same request is perceived as assertive when a man makes it and as demanding when a woman does, and "presence" is a convenient place for that bias to hide.
The quiz
Over the past month, answer yes or no to each statement. Count only what actually occurred, not what you imagine you would have done.
A. Whenever you make a suggestion, you lead with the suggestion itself and only afterward explain how you got there.
B. In a meeting, you voiced a objection to a senior colleague in front of everyone.
C. You're able to explain what your team exists to do in a single sentence that someone outside your field would understand right away.
D. When a problem surfaces, colleagues bring it to you first instead of bypassing you to reach someone higher up.
E. In a meeting, you allow a silence to stretch out rather than scrambling to cover it.
F. You admitted, "I don't have that answer yet, and I'll track it down by Thursday," and then you actually delivered it.
G. Your messages to top executives are briefer than what those executives write back to you.
H. When a senior person asked you for something you couldn't do, you declined and explained why in one tight sentence.
I. You kept a calm, steady bearing in a room where everyone else was coming apart.
J. At a later meeting, someone quoted one of your own lines back to you.
Reading your score
Roughly eight to ten, a solid and settled number. Colleagues in the Raleigh room already see you as someone who makes the calls. If the feedback keeps coming, find out who is delivering it and what they truly intend, since it may say more about them than about you.
Four to seven: developing. Your judgment is sound, and you already project some of that signal. What is mostly missing is speed and economy: the recommendation up front, the tighter email, the pause you leave alone while the room catches up.
Zero to three: capable yet understated, as many Raleigh leaders in the Triangle have found. You generate the output and let others settle what it is worth. Quietness of this kind is not a personal failing. Plenty of us were coached to walk through our reasoning before anyone had reason to trust our conclusion, which served us well in school but works against us in the boardroom.
What to do next
Eight to ten: the next time someone in a Triangle meeting raises "presence," ask, "What specifically would you want to see differently in the next meeting?" Note the reply. When no answer comes, you've uncovered something about the feedback itself rather than about yourself.
Scoring four to seven, commit for one month to opening each update with the decision you require in its first sentence. Change nothing else. Notice how the room responds.
Scoring zero to three, at your next meeting, raise one brief disagreement with the most senior person present, then deliberately stop speaking. One sentence is enough. Try something like, "I see it differently, and let me explain why," and then give them room to answer. The pause that follows is where the presence sits.
Tally your yeses, and pass this along to the woman who was told she lacks presence and never got an explanation of what that meant.